Does the perfect control unit for the intelligent home exist? No, but there are solutions that offer clear advantages thanks to the support of numerous radio technologies.
According to Bitkom, the proportion of smart home users rose from 26 to 41 percent between 2018 and 2021. Smart technology has prevailed, especially for the control of light. But also the regulation of the room temperature with smart thermostats (best list) is becoming more and more popular. With surveillance cameras, motion detectors (guides) , flood sensors and smoke detectors, your own home is also safer. And last but not least, the technology with smart irrigation systems (guide) also opens up the garden area. The control possibilities seem to know no limits. At least in theory. In practice, unfortunately, things look a little different.
The various smart home systems usually cover many application scenarios. With the help of a motion detector, you can switch on the light or the television, for example. More complex automations are also possible, provided the necessary sensors and actuators are supported. But if you want to control a new air purifier (guide) more efficiently with the help of a powerful room air measuring device (guide) like the Air-Q, you will find that there are many devices outside of these systems that cannot be easily integrated. The problem does not only affect exotic application scenarios, but almost all smart devices such as sockets , switches and dimmers ,Lighting , thermostats for radiators and underfloor heating , and surveillance cameras .
The “Matter” standard, which is expected for autumn 2022, is intended to ensure more compatibility, with the aim of making corresponding devices independent of the manufacturer platform. Whether and especially when the new standard can actually solve the compatibility problem remains to be seen.
Until then, if users want to be as free as possible when choosing smart products, they need a smart home center that is compatible with existing solutions. In addition to WLAN, such a control unit must also support at least the energy-optimized Zigbee and Z-Wave radio technologies developed for the smart home sector . But that alone is not enough, after all, some components also transmit via Bluetooth or in the 433 and 868 MHz bands. And if you want to integrate older infrared devices into your smart home, you should make sure that you have the appropriate support.
1st place: Homey Pro
The smart home center Homey Pro (test report) comes from the Dutch company Athom. Apart from the little-used Enocean standard, it supports all wireless technologies relevant to the smart home sector, such as WLAN, Zigbee, Z-Wave, Bluetooth and infrared, and also transmits in the 433 MHz and 868 MHz bands used by older smart homes devices are used. According to the manufacturer, more than 50,000 devices can be connected with each other.
Managing all the components in a smart home under one interface is not possible with Homey Pro either. But the small sphere with the glowing LED equator comes very close to this dream and offers significantly more than solutions from other manufacturers. If you want, you can even use it to manage KNX-based smart home environments or monitor the production of your photovoltaic system . And Homey Pro can also control the DECT-ULE components connected to a Fritzbox, such as sockets and heating thermostats. The user-friendly interface is not only available in the form of a mobile app, but can also be conveniently accessed from the desktop.
With the services offered, Homey Pro is primarily of interest to users who want to consolidate many apps for controlling smart home components and for whom open source solutions based on Iobroker or Home Assistant are too complex. Thanks to its open architecture with great community support and apps, Homey Pro is a versatile and easy-to-use solution for this target group, with which they are not only dependent on a single manufacturer and possibly expensive solutions when expanding their smart home.
Homey Pro is like a Raspberry with many antennas and an elegant and powerful operating system that offers clear advantages over the competition in terms of setup, maintenance and connection, even if it doesn’t quite come close to the functionality of an open source solution. But this performance has its price: users have to shell out almost 400 euros for Homey Pro (test report) . But they are well put together. With Homey Bridge for 69 euros, Athom also offers a cloud-based solution that incurs monthly costs of 2.99 euros for the full range of services.
2nd place: Samsung Smartthings
Samsung Smartthings (test report) is one of the most popular smart home platforms in the USA and Great Britain . This is also reflected in the reporting: In its smart home blog The Wirecutter, the New York Times also mentions smart things from Samsung in addition to Amazon Alexa, Apple Home Kit and Google Assistant when it comes to the compatibility of smart home components.
Smartthings is not that popular in this country. After the failed attempt to market the platform together with Vodafone in Germany and monthly subscription costs, Z-Wave Europe is now responsible for selling the smart home center. The distributor for Z-Wave-compatible products belongs to the Hamburg-based Aeotec Group, which is why its name adorns the Smartthings headquarters. Samsung itself is increasingly integrating Smartthings hubs into household appliances, TVs and smart monitors.
The Smartthings center from Aeotec integrates the most important wireless technologies in the smart home sector with WLAN, Zigbee and Z-Wave. Despite some problems with the integration of devices from other manufacturers, the compatibility of the Smartthings platform can be viewed positively. These include a large number of prominent brands from the smart home sector, such as Bose, Danfoss, Fibaro, Home Connect, Honeywell, Ikea (Tradfri), Nanoleaf, Netatmo, Philips Hue, Ring, Somfy, Sonoff, Sonos, Tapo and Tint .
Thanks to its compatibility with products from over 200 manufacturers, Smartthings is a good basis for managing a smart home. Since Samsung is one of the main drivers of the Matter standard, users can assume that the platform will become even more versatile in the future, since the new standard should make it even easier to integrate components from different manufacturers and to execute rules locally. Aeotec charges around 100 euros for the Smartthings hub.